SecretStash vs. Doppler
By Doug Niccum, founder of SecretStash
Pick SecretStash if you're a small team that wants flat pricing: $10/month covers up to 20 users, while Doppler's Team plan is $21 per user, or $420/month for twenty. Pick Doppler if you need SAML SSO or automatic secret rotation today. SecretStash has neither, and Doppler's free Developer plan covers up to 3 users.
| Feature | SecretStash | Doppler |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Flat rate per organization tier | Per-seat, billed per user/month |
| Free tier | No free plan; 14-day trial | Developer plan, free for first 3 users |
| CLI workflow | CLI-first pull/push | CLI available alongside dashboard-first workflow |
| Client-side encryption | Zero-knowledge, encrypted before upload | Server-side encryption at rest |
| SSO / SAML | Coming soon (Enterprise tier, via WorkOS) | Included on Team tier and above |
| Automatic secret rotation | Not available | Included on Team tier and above |
| Activity logs | Included on all paid plans | Included, retention varies by tier |
Pricing at a glance
- Doppler Developer: free for the first 3 users, then $8/user/month.
- Doppler Team: $21/user/month.
- Doppler Enterprise: custom pricing.
- SecretStash Team: a flat $10/month (or $100/year) for up to 20 users — no per-seat math required.
- SecretStash Organization: a flat $40/month (or $400/year) for unlimited users.
How much does each cost as your team grows?
Monthly cost at common team sizes, using the list prices above.
| Team size | SecretStash | Doppler Team ($21/user) |
|---|---|---|
| 3 users | $10/month (Team) | $63/month |
| 5 users | $10/month (Team) | $105/month |
| 10 users | $10/month (Team) | $210/month |
| 20 users | $10/month (Team) | $420/month |
Doppler's Developer plan is free for the first 3 users, so a team of 3 or fewer that doesn't need Team-tier features may pay nothing on Doppler. Past 20 users, SecretStash's Organization plan is a flat $40/month with no user cap.
Which one fits your team?
Choose SecretStash if…
You're a small Laravel or Node team that wants predictable, flat pricing regardless of headcount, and you're comfortable with a CLI-first workflow rather than a full secrets-ops platform.
Choose Doppler if…
You need SAML SSO today, not on a roadmap. Or you need automatic secret rotation or dynamic secrets, which SecretStash does not plan to build.
How do you switch from Doppler to SecretStash?
Moving from Doppler is a one-time export and push. Your code keeps reading the same .env values, so nothing in the app itself changes.
- Export each Doppler config (dev, staging, production) to a .env file on your machine. The Doppler CLI can download secrets in .env format.
- Create an account at secretstash.cloud. New organizations start with a 14-day trial. In the dashboard, click "New application" and create one environment per file you exported (for example, local, staging, production).
- In your Laravel app, run
composer require dniccum/secret-stash-cli, thenphp artisan secret-stash:loginto authorize the CLI in your browser. SetSECRET_STASH_APPLICATION_IDin your.envto the ID shown for your application. - Run
php artisan secret-stash:install. This creates the key that encrypts your values on your machine. It lives in~/.secret-stash/device_private_key.pem, so keep that directory safe. - Push each exported file into its environment, for example
php artisan secret-stash:variables push --environment=production --file=.env.production. Values are encrypted before they leave your machine. - Invite teammates to your organization from the dashboard. Each one installs the CLI, runs
php artisan secret-stash:login, and runsphp artisan secret-stash:keys initonce on their machine. - Sharing works one environment at a time. Run
php artisan secret-stash:share --environment=productionfor each environment (staging, local, and so on), then teammates pull withphp artisan secret-stash:variables pull --environment=production. - Delete the plaintext export files once everything is pushed, so they don't end up in Slack or Git later.
What doesn't SecretStash do yet?
Check these before you switch. If one is a hard requirement, Doppler may be the better fit today.
- No SAML SSO yet. Enterprise SSO via WorkOS is on the roadmap, not shipped.
- No automatic secret rotation or dynamic secrets, and none planned.
- Not SOC 2 certified.
Common questions about Doppler
Sources
Doppler pricing verified against doppler.com/pricing. Figures current as of September 2026 and subject to change.